Andy and John's revelation has everyone intrigued. The post Andy Cohen Confirms Sex Tape With Ex-Boyfriend John Hill appeared first on Reality Tea.

Hill and Cohen dated for three years in the early 2000s, when Hill was still a part of the original Broadway cast of 'Hairspray'

Andy Cohen and John Hill’s sex tape has once again become a topic of conversation. At the end of Tuesday night’s (Jan. 7) episode of Watch What Happens Live, Hill — who is Cohen’s ex-boyfriend and trusty Radio Andy co-host — counted down the top five things the Bravo icon should do in 2025.

Yes, Andy Cohen and ex John Hill did make a sex tape when they were together - but don't expect it to see the light of day. Hill, 46, was the bartender during the Tuesday, January 7 episode of Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen.

Andy Cohen confirmed there is X-rated evidence of his relationship with ex-boyfriend John Hill somewhere out there. Hill brought up the pair’s old sex during Tuesday’s “Watch What Happens Live” episode while listing “the top five things” Cohen should do in 2025.

The Watch What Happens Live host, 56, was joined by his former flame, 46, John Hill, on Tuesday night's episode of his talk show. During one segment on the episode, the guests were invited to suggest "What Andy Should Do in 2025".